Harnett County Public Schools plan to close bilingual immersion programs (DLI) in several elementary schools by April 2026, a decision that has generated rejection from parents, teachers and students in the county.
Following complaints expressed during a School Board meeting at the end of last month, parents organized a virtual information session this Tuesday, April 14, with Maria Coady, a professor of multilingual education at North Carolina State University, to explain what DLI programs are and what the research shows.
What are bilingual immersion programs?
Bilingual immersion programs are educational models in which students learn academic subjects in two languages, usually English and Spanish.
According to North Carolina Department of Public Instruction, The state has been a leader in dual language immersion programs for more than 30 years, with the first program starting in the fall of 1990. It currently has more than 300 such programs in the education system, from elementary to high school, taught in eight languages: Cherokee, Chinese, French, German, Greek, Japanese, Spanish, and Urdu.
Who are these programs designed for?
The questions: “Who participates in the program?” and “For whom are they designed?” are very common in conversations when these programs are questioned.
For Coady, the answer is simple: they are aimed at all students.
Different types of bilingual immersion programs
The expert also explained that there are two types of dual-language immersion programs:
- one-way immersion programs.
- bidirectional immersion programs.
| One-way immersion programs, or “one-way” immersion programs | Bidirectional immersion programs, or “two-way” |
| They occur when there are students who come, for the most part, from the same linguistic environment; that is, who mostly speak the same language. | They occur when half of the students come from a certain linguistic environment, while the other half come from a different linguistic environment. |
North Carolina, Coady explained, has mostly “one-way” dual language programs.
“This is because in some communities there are a large number of English speakers. And in those communities, children receive the same type of instruction: most of their early education is given in Spanish, with English being gradually incorporated later. However, most of these students come from the same linguistic background,” Coady explained.
However, with regard to most of the programs in the Harnett community, for example, the one at Coats Elementary School, they are classified in the category of “two-way” bilingual education.
“Coats Elementary is an example of a school founded as a bilingual, two-way immersion program. It was founded because the community had both Spanish and English speakers, and the school, as well as the children, benefits from instruction in both languages,” Coady said.
Related>> Honor Preparatory: Bilingual charter school in Charlotte opens new spaces
How does teaching work in bilingual immersion programs?
One part of bilingual immersion, Coady said, is the amount of instruction in the minority language, which progressively increases to 50% or more by third grade.
In the early elementary grades, programs typically begin with instruction focused on literacy in the minority language and then gradually incorporate English. Later, in the upper grades, students receive balanced instruction in both languages.
“By third and fourth grade, most dual immersion programs are already 50-50, meaning students learn half of their subjects in Spanish and the other half in English,” Coady said.
At this point, some bilingual programs stop. Coady said that's what they don't want to happen.
"Why? Because the benefits of bilingualism become apparent in grades four, five, six, and seven. These benefits become more apparent as children remain in the programs longer."

The benefits
Students gain academic, economic, and cognitive benefits.
On a cognitive level, Coady explained that the brains of multilingual people process information quickly when determining which language to use, with whom, when, and how.
“How their thinking and reasoning develops through different languages; that is the cognitive benefit of bilingual programs,” Coady said.
The expert also emphasized the difference between a bilingual immersion program and a foreign language class. The goal of DLI programs is for students to become fully bilingual and biliterate, capable of reasoning in two languages, something that, according to her, is not achieved in traditional language classes.
“And it is precisely there, in being bilingual, that the true benefits become apparent. It is not simply a foreign language; it is not the same thing,” Coady explained.



Thank you so much for the explanation of the dual immersion bilingual programs. These programs have so many benefits, and it's sad that people aren't more informed about them. Thanks for sharing.